Trucking Safety Ratings Face Scrutiny Over Data Disparities
The American Trucking Associations questions the current safety rating system, citing unfair ratings due to geographic enforcement variations and data quality issues. The Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association also criticizes the system's failure to effectively reduce accidents. The Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance advocates for simplifying the rating to a single “Unsatisfactory” standard. The National Association of Small Trucking Companies deems the existing system “terrible” and suggests improvements. These organizations highlight significant concerns regarding the fairness, accuracy, and effectiveness of the current safety rating system for commercial vehicles.









