The US rail freight industry experienced a slight downturn in the first week of September, according to the latest data from the Association of American Railroads (AAR). The Labor Day holiday appears to have contributed to year-over-year declines in both total rail carloads and intermodal units. But does this indicate a long-term trend reversal or merely temporary volatility?
Freight Volume Overview: Short-Term Decline vs. Long-Term Growth
For the week ending September 6, total US rail carloads reached 214,383, marking a 3.5% decrease compared to the same period last year. Intermodal containers and trailers totaled 253,497 units, down 1.4% year-over-year. The decline becomes more apparent when compared to previous weeks (234,740 carloads for August 30 week and 229,783 for August 23 week), highlighting the direct impact of the Labor Day holiday on freight activity.
Cumulative data through the first 36 weeks of 2025 tells a different story: US rail carloads reached 7,963,526, representing a 2.4% increase, while intermodal units totaled 9,724,964, up 4.0% year-over-year. This suggests that despite short-term holiday effects, underlying demand for rail freight remains robust.
Commodity Analysis: Mixed Performance Reflects Economic Shifts
Beneath the overall decline, different commodity groups showed divergent performance, reflecting structural changes in the US economy:
-
Growth Leaders:
- Miscellaneous freight: Increased by 1,132 carloads to 8,512, likely reflecting stable consumer demand and rail's advantage in transporting smaller, high-value shipments.
- Motor vehicles & parts: Grew by 973 carloads to 14,633, driven by automotive industry recovery and increased electric vehicle production.
- Forest products: Rose by 286 carloads to 7,801, supported by steady housing construction and paper product demand.
-
Declining Sectors:
- Chemicals: Dropped by 2,875 carloads to 29,802, potentially due to manufacturing slowdowns and international trade tensions.
- Coal: Fell by 2,824 carloads to 60,927, continuing its downward trend amid environmental policies and renewable energy growth.
- Grain: Decreased by 1,570 carloads to 18,067, possibly due to seasonal agricultural patterns and international competition.
Intermodal Market: Slower Growth With Untapped Potential
The 1.4% year-over-year decline in intermodal units suggests slowing growth in this critical rail segment, potentially influenced by trucking competition, port congestion, and supply chain bottlenecks.
However, intermodal retains significant growth potential as e-commerce expansion increases demand for efficient long-haul transportation. Government support for multimodal transportation infrastructure may further bolster this sector.
Key Takeaways
1. Holiday Effects: Labor Day's temporary impact on business activity makes the September data an unreliable indicator of broader economic health.
2. Economic Transition: The commodity mix reveals America's ongoing shift from traditional industries (coal) toward emerging sectors (EV components).
3. Supply Chain Pressures: Rail operators must address port congestion and trucker shortages through improved coordination.
4. Competitive Landscape: Rail must innovate service models and reduce costs to maintain market share against trucking.
Outlook
Despite short-term challenges, the US rail freight industry's long-term prospects remain positive. Economic growth, infrastructure investment, and technological innovation will likely strengthen rail's role in national logistics. Industry players must adapt to market changes while capitalizing on emerging opportunities.