Study Finds Shippers Carriers Align on Transport Industry Priorities

A new Breakthrough study reveals three key areas of consensus between shippers and carriers in the next 12 months: reducing emissions, building mutually beneficial contract relationships, and navigating fluctuations in linehaul rates. The report emphasizes collaboration, innovation, and sustainability as crucial for industry advancement. It provides strategic insights for businesses to address challenges and capitalize on opportunities, highlighting the importance of working together to achieve shared goals in a dynamic freight landscape. This research offers valuable guidance for navigating the evolving transportation sector.
Study Finds Shippers Carriers Align on Transport Industry Priorities

In today's rapidly evolving economic landscape, supply chains function as the lifeblood of commerce, with freight transportation serving as the powerful engine that keeps this system moving. While the industry's growth signals economic vitality, it simultaneously faces mounting environmental pressures, contractual disputes, and volatile pricing—challenges that test the resilience of every stakeholder.

A new report from transportation solutions provider Breakthrough, titled "2023 State of Transportation" , offers critical insights into how the industry is addressing these challenges. The comprehensive study surveyed 500 U.S. transportation stakeholders (including both shippers and carriers) to identify three primary objectives for the coming year: emissions reduction, mutually beneficial contracts, and adapting to fluctuating linehaul rates.

Emissions Reduction: A Shared Priority Facing Implementation Hurdles

The report reveals overwhelming consensus on sustainability, with 94% of respondents identifying emissions reduction as a key priority. Notably, 99% of shippers expressed willingness to utilize electric or alternative-fuel vehicles if available in carrier networks, while 97% of carriers recognized the value of incorporating such vehicles—with 59% planning concrete actions by year's end.

"The greatest challenge lies in securing organizational buy-in across all stakeholders," explained Breakthrough Chief Economist Matt Muenster. "Short-term costs can be substantial with delayed ROI, while limited visibility into supply chain emissions data makes establishing baselines and tracking progress exceptionally difficult."

Breakthrough addresses these challenges through data-driven emissions tracking platforms, customized strategy consulting, alternative energy solutions (including electric vehicles and biofuels), modal optimization (shifting freight to rail where possible), and partnerships with EPA SmartWay-certified carriers.

Contract Relationships: Moving From Adversarial to Collaborative Models

Seventy percent of surveyed stakeholders identified improved contract relationships as a 2023 priority—a shift Breakthrough interprets as signaling industry movement toward more cooperative frameworks. Traditional adversarial negotiations often created inflexible terms vulnerable to disputes, particularly in today's volatile market conditions.

"Transparency around accessorial charges and fuel costs strengthens shipper-carrier relationships," Muenster noted. "Aligning with partners who share common values—whether around efficiency or sustainability—creates win-win opportunities. Performance incentives demonstrating long-term commitment are equally crucial."

The company advocates transparent pricing mechanisms, flexible contract terms adaptable to market shifts, shared goal-setting between parties, performance-based incentives, and fostering long-term partnerships through consistent volumes.

Rate Volatility: Navigating Uncertain Pricing Landscapes

With 63% of respondents anticipating above-average linehaul rates due to rising labor and equipment costs—contrasting Breakthrough's internal data suggesting potential year-end stabilization—the report emphasizes strategic procurement approaches.

"Shippers should carefully evaluate capacity sourcing partners," advised Muenster. "Building strategic relationships with service-proven carriers helps stabilize costs across market cycles. While spot markets currently offer short-term savings, overreliance risks exposure when conditions shift."

Breakthrough supports shippers through market analytics, procurement strategy development, spot market management tools, risk assessment frameworks, and data-driven decision platforms.

Additional Findings: Collaboration and Efficiency Gains

The study uncovered supplementary priorities including:

  • 50% of respondents prioritizing new partnerships to enhance efficiency
  • 33% focusing on breaking down internal silos hindering operational decisions
  • 33% committed to science-based emissions targets
  • 29% emphasizing supplier network consolidation

Industry Outlook: Cooperation, Innovation and Sustainability

The report positions collaboration, technological advancement, and environmental responsibility as defining themes for transportation's future. As stakeholders increasingly recognize their interdependence in addressing systemic challenges, solutions like those offered by Breakthrough aim to transform obstacles into opportunities for collective progress.