Multimodal Freight Market Strains Amid Capacity Shortages Higher Costs

The North American Multimodal Transportation Association's annual meeting highlighted the dual challenges of capacity constraints and rising costs facing freight companies. The report analyzes the current state and trends in trucking and rail transportation, proposing strategies for shippers to cope with these challenges. It emphasizes the importance of data-driven decision-making and forecasts the future direction of multimodal transportation. The meeting stressed the need for adaptability and strategic planning in the face of evolving market dynamics within the freight and supply chain landscape.
Multimodal Freight Market Strains Amid Capacity Shortages Higher Costs

The supply chain serves as a barometer for economic health. When freight costs continue to climb and capacity bottlenecks emerge, how should businesses prepare for the approaching autumn shipping peak?

At the recent Intermodal Association of North America (IANA) annual exhibition in Long Beach, freight companies received mixed signals about future truck and rail capacity. While truck capacity tightens and contract rates rise, rail transport struggles with efficiency improvements and service level stagnation. This dual challenge of rising costs and potential delays will test shippers during the upcoming peak season. Drawing on analysis from FTR Transportation Intelligence, this article examines current intermodal market conditions and trends to inform shippers' decision-making.

1. Macro Environment: A Pressured Freight Market

FTR's Shippers Conditions Index (SCI), a key indicator of transportation market conditions, registered -7.8 in July—a 1.3-point decline from June. Values below zero indicate unfavorable shipping conditions, while readings below -10 suggest critical capacity shortages and sustained high rates.

Key factors driving the SCI decline include:

  • Truck capacity constraints: Economic recovery has increased demand for trucking, but driver shortages and rising maintenance costs limit capacity growth.
  • Contract rate increases: Carriers are raising prices to offset capacity constraints, squeezing shippers' profit margins.
  • Approaching peak season: Autumn retail demand will intensify capacity pressures as goods move from production centers to distribution networks.

"Our recent annual transportation conference reinforced our view that the freight market remains tight," noted Jonathan Starks, FTR's Director of Transportation Analysis.

2. Rail Transport: Efficiency Gains Remain Elusive

As a critical intermodal component, rail efficiency directly impacts total shipping costs and delivery times. However, FTR intermodal analyst Larry Gross cautioned that shippers shouldn't expect rail speed improvements this year, with service levels likely remaining flat.

Rail networks face multiple challenges:

  • Infrastructure bottlenecks: Key segments and hubs operate at capacity, with upgrades requiring significant time and capital.
  • Operational inefficiencies: Complex coordination between scheduling, loading, and transfers creates systemic vulnerabilities.
  • Weather disruptions: Extreme events increasingly cause line closures and delays.

3. Strategies for Shippers: Balancing Challenges and Opportunities

While market conditions present difficulties, Starks believes the industry can manage most challenges with limited capacity shortfalls. "The positive outlook is that most challenges will be manageable, though truck rates will continue climbing throughout the year," he explained. "Even limited shortages may require extra effort to move non-optimized freight, potentially causing delays."

Shippers should consider these mitigation strategies:

  • Advance planning: Forecast demand early and secure capacity through long-term carrier relationships.
  • Mode optimization: Evaluate intermodal combinations and improve packaging/loading efficiency.
  • Supply chain visibility: Implement tracking technologies and enhance partner collaboration.
  • Operational flexibility: Monitor market dynamics and maintain contingency plans.
  • Technology adoption: Leverage supply chain software and analytics for route optimization.

4. Data-Driven Decision Making for Shipping Optimization

In volatile markets, analytics enable smarter shipping strategies through:

  • Historical shipment analysis to identify bottlenecks
  • Real-time rate monitoring across lanes and modes
  • Weather and traffic pattern forecasting
  • Carrier performance benchmarking

These datasets help shippers predict demand, optimize routes, mitigate risks, and improve operational efficiency.

5. The Future of Intermodal: Digital Transformation

Intermodal transport is evolving toward:

  • Smart systems: AI/ML applications for predictive analytics and automated routing
  • Digital integration: Blockchain and IoT for enhanced transparency and security
  • Sustainability: Eco-friendly transport solutions and energy-efficient operations

Current intermodal markets face dual pressures from constrained capacity and rising costs. By implementing proactive strategies, enhancing visibility, and leveraging data analytics, shippers can navigate these challenges effectively. The industry's ongoing digital transformation promises to create new opportunities for efficiency and resilience in global supply chains.